Hardneck Garlic vs Softneck Garlic: Which Is Right for Your Garden?

Are you trying to decide between hardneck garlic and softneck garlic for your garden? Knowing what's the right variety for you and your garden will help you choose the best option. In this post we’ll go over the differences in growing conditions, flavour profiles and storage to help you decide which one is the preferred choice for you.

Quick Facts

• Hardneck garlic grows in cold climates, has a rigid stalk, fewer bigger cloves and big flavour, and is a favourite among gourmet chefs.

• Softneck garlic has a flexible neck, many smaller cloves and mild flavour, longer storage life and is adaptable for warmer climates.

• Choosing the right garlic for your garden depends on your local climate, hardneck for colder areas and softneck for warmer areas, plus proper planting and care.

What is Hardneck and Softneck Garlic

Garlic is in every kitchen around the world, but not all garlic is created equal. The two main types of garlic—hardneck and softneck—each have their own characteristics that will affect your gardening and cooking. Knowing these differences will help gardeners grow garlic better.

Hardneck garlic, scientifically known as Allium sativum ssp. ophioscorodon, has a rigid central stalk and fewer, bigger cloves. This type grows in cold climates and is prized for its big flavour and garlic scapes, a gourmet in itself. Many chefs love hard neck garlic for its special taste.

Softneck garlic, without a rigid central stalk, has many smaller cloves and a flexible neck, perfect for braiding. Softneck is prized for its mild garlic flavour and longer shelf life, so it’s the type you’ll find most in grocery stores.

The differences between hardneck and softneck garlic go beyond the physical structure. From how they grow to flavour profiles and storage, each type has its own perks. As we get into the specifics of each type you’ll see which one might be best for your garden and cooking.

Hardneck Garlic

Hardneck garlic is a favourite among gourmet chefs and garlic lovers for its special characteristics. Big, easy to peel cloves with a big punchy flavour this garlic is a real showstopper in the culinary world. 

Structure and Clove Arrangement

Hardneck garlic is easy to identify by its rigid central stalk, called a scape, that emerges from the centre of the bulb. This scape is not only a visual marker but a culinary delight, often harvested and used in many dishes.

The cloves of hardneck garlic are arranged in a single layer around this central stalk, usually 10 or fewer but bigger than softneck cloves. The bigger cloves are wrapped tightly together, making them easy to peel and perfect for cooking.

This arrangement may give fewer cloves per bulb but gives more intense flavour and simplifies planting and harvesting. The rigid stalk also gives a structural advantage, making it easy to separate individual cloves when preparing.

Flavour Profile

If you like big, complex flavors in your cooking, hardneck garlic is your go to. This type is famous for its big and pungent flavor, more so than softneck garlic. The rich, bold flavor of hardneck garlic is perfect for gourmet dishes, that’s why many chefs and home cooks love it.

The clove arrangement of hardneck garlic is a big contributor to its flavor profile. Each clove is a powerhouse, delivering more concentrated garlic flavor to any dish. Varieties like Spanish Roja are famous for their rich and classic flavor, that’s why they’re a favorite among garlic lovers.

Growing Conditions

Hardneck garlic thrives in cold climates. Cold exposure is essential for the bulb to grow well, that’s why these types are perfect for areas with harsh winters. Plant your hardneck garlic in the Autumn so it can grow during the cold winter months to set up for a great harvest.

To grow hardneck garlic well, make sure your soil is well draining and full of organic matter. This type of garlic likes soil that’s rich in nutrients so it can produce big and flavourful bulbs. Regular maintenance like cutting the scapes is also important to redirect energy to bulb growth so you can have a big harvest.

Softneck Garlic

Softneck garlic is the most common type, which is usually found in grocery stores. Loved for its versatility and longer shelf life, which makes softneck garlic a household staple.

Structure and Clove Arrangement

Unlike hardneck garlic, softneck garlic doesn’t produce a rigid central stalk. Instead it has a flexible neck that’s easy to braid after harvest. This flexibility is one of the reasons softneck garlic is loved by gardeners and home cooks. The cloves in softneck garlic are smaller and more, packed tightly in the bulb.

Varieties like Solent Wight are recommended for its ease of braiding and long storage life. Sometimes these plants may produce a flowering stalk when stressed but that’s rare.

Flavour Profile

Softneck garlic is known for its mild garlic flavour, sweeter and less pungent than hardneck. That’s why it’s good for everyday cooking, its flavour is versatile and loved by many palates.

Softneck garlic has longer shelf life so you can enjoy its flavour for months after harvest.

Growing Conditions

Softneck garlic grows best in warm climates, that’s why it’s perfect for gardeners in milder areas. This type of garlic likes full sun and well draining, neutral to alkaline soil. Consistent moisture is important but avoid waterlogging as both drought and excess water can reduce bulb size.

To grow well:

1. Add organic matter and nutrients like nitrogen and potassium to your soil.

2. Water your plants regularly and protect them from extreme cold to help softneck garlic grow and have a big harvest.

3. Mulch to retain moisture and suppress weeds.

Choosing the Right Garlic for Your Garden

Choosing the right garlic for your garden involves considering several factors, climate, planting method and maintenance. By knowing the difference between hardneck and softneck garlic you can make a smart decision to grow garlic.

First evaluate your climate to know which type of garlic is best for you. We now know Hardneck garlic grows well in cold climate, softneck in warmer areas.

Now let's learn the best planting method for healthy growth and big harvest and also consider the maintenance and care requirements to keep your garlic plants healthy throughout the growing season.

Climate Suitability

When choosing between hardneck and softneck garlic, climate suitability is a big factor. Hardneck garlic varieties are cold hardy and grows well in areas with cold winters, benefits from cold exposure that promotes bulb development. If you’re in an area with cold winters, hardneck garlic is probably the best for your garden.

Softneck garlic is better for warmer climates. It can adapt to milder winters and grows well in areas with temperate weather. Knowing your local climate will guide you in choosing the right garlic for a successful and fun gardening experience.

Planting Method

Planting garlic requires some preparation and attention. Start by dividing the garlic bulbs into individual cloves, keep the papery covering intact to protect them during planting. For both hardneck and softneck varieties the best planting time is between October to March so the bulbs will mature by July.

Plant the cloves pointy end up, 2.5 cm deep and 15 cm apart in well draining soil. Space the rows 30 cm apart for good growth.

For hardneck garlic, cutting the scapes as they form will direct more energy to bulb formation and will result to bigger and more flavourful bulbs.

Maintenance and Care

Proper maintenance and care is important to grow garlic well. Regular weeding is necessary to minimize competition and to keep garlic plants healthy. Consistent watering especially during dry spell is needed to support bulb formation and to prevent stress.

Mulch with straw or shredded leaves to retain moisture and suppress weeds around the garlic plants to create a better growing environment. Also removing flower scapes as they form will redirect energy to bulb growth and will result to bigger harvest and better quality of your garlic.

Harvesting and Storing Your Garlic

Harvesting and storing garlic is the last step to enjoy the fruits of your labour. Knowing the right time and method to harvest and how to cure and store your garlic will keep your bulbs healthy for months.

Hardneck garlic is best eaten fresh as it doesn’t store well as softneck varieties. Softneck garlic has longer shelf life and can be stored up to 12 months under right conditions.

Now let’s look at the harvesting method and storage technique for both.

Harvesting Method

Best time to harvest garlic is when several lower leaves turn brown and five or six upper leaves are still green. This means the bulbs are mature and ready for harvest. Don’t pull the bulbs by their stems, instead loosen the soil around them with a spading fork to prevent damage and for a successful harvest.

After harvesting, gently brush off excess soil and lay the bulbs to dry in a shaded area with good air circulation. This initial drying period is important to prevent sun damage and to prepare the garlic for curing.

Curing and Storage

Curing garlic is important for long term storage. After harvesting leave the garlic bulbs with their leaves intact and place them in a shaded area with good air circulation to dry for 2 to 3 weeks. This will allow the garlic to lose excess moisture while retaining its flavour and texture. Once cured, trim the roots and cut the stems about an inch above the bulb.

For storage, keep your cured garlic in a cool, dark place with temperature between10-15°C (50 to 60°F) degrees Fahrenheit. Softneck garlic varieties like Solent Wight can store up to 12 months under right conditions. Properly stored garlic will let you enjoy its flavour beyond harvest season.

Other Garlic Varieties to Try

Trying unique garlic varieties will add fun to your gardening and cooking. While hardneck and softneck are the main types, there are several other varieties to try.

Garlic Solent Wight, Garlic Kingsland Wight, Garlic Provence Wight, Elephant Garlic.

Garlic Solent Wight

Garlic Solent Wight is one of the best garlic variety for eating and keeping quality. This softneck variety has strong flavour and long storage life. Best time to plant Garlic Solent Wight is from November to January but can also be planted in late March for good results.

It’s reliable and taste is a favourite among garlic lovers.

Garlic Kingsland Wight

Garlic Kingsland Wight is a hardneck variety that some French consider the best tasting of all French garlic. It can be planted in autumn and early spring so it’s adaptable to various conditions.

This variety is famous for its flavour so it’s a great choice for gourmet dishes.

Garlic Provence Wight

Garlic Provence Wight is a large white softneck garlic that produces big bulbs. Best planted in autumn, can also be sown in spring but will yield smaller bulbs. Robust flavour and big size makes it good for everyday cooking to gourmet recipes.

Common Problems and Solutions

Growing garlic can have its challenges but knowing the common problems and their solutions will help you to have healthy plants. Pests like Allium leaf mining fly and leek moth can damage garlic crops. Introducing natural predators and crop rotation can help manage these pests.

Diseases like leek rust and downy mildew can also affect garlic plants. Leek rust causes orange pustules on the leaves, downy mildew causes yellow spots and grey fuzzy growth. Good air circulation and no overhead watering can minimize the risk of these diseases. Fusarium root rot is a serious problem that makes it not recommended to replant garlic in the same soil for at least 2 years.

Knowing these common problems and taking preventive measures will have a healthy and productive garlic garden. Monitoring regularly and act fast is key to overcome these challenges and have a good harvest.

Conclusion

Growing your own garlic is fun, you’ll have fresh and flavourful bulbs for your recipes. Knowing the difference between hardneck and softneck garlic, choosing the right variety for your climate and following the right planting and care will make you grow garlic successfully. Don’t forget to try unique varieties and be ready to face common problems to have a big harvest. Happy gardening!

FAQ

What’s the best garlic for eating and keeping?

• Garlic Solent Wight is good for eating and keeping. It’s good for both culinary use and long term storage.

What’s special about Garlic Kingsland Wight?

• Garlic Kingsland Wight is special for being a hardneck variety that some French consider the best tasting garlic from France. Its flavour is unique for culinary use.

When to plant Garlic Rhapsody Wight for best results?

• Plant Garlic Rhapsody Wight between September and December.

How deep to plant garlic cloves?

• Plant garlic cloves 3cm in the soil for better growth. Don’t bury them too deep to promote healthy sprouting.

When to plant Garlic Solent Wight?

• Best time to plant Garlic Solent Wight is from November to January but can also yield well if planted at the end of March. Planting during these periods will give you better growth and harvest.